Using Riddles as Medical Teaching Tools
In a recent article in The American Journal of Medicine (AMjMED), Stanford Medicine 25’s Abraham Verghese advocates for riddles as a teaching tactic. With co-author Andrew Elder and other colleagues from Stanford and UW School of Medicine, Verghese describes a riddle as an educational “exercise” that “requires thought and deliberate practice, qualities that have their benefits in many aspects of clinical care.” The authors suggest that medical examinations should be presented in the form of riddles to promote “the development of analytical thought,” a skill we know to be beneficial while conducting physical exams at the bedside and determining a diagnosis.
In 2009, Verghese authored Teaching Medicine, One Mystery as a Time which reminds us that “since ancient times, riddles have served as teaching tools [because] the point of the riddle, at least the medical riddle, is to search your brain, then search your books or the library, then connect the dots.” Medical riddles provoke thinking and analysis, inspiring more in-depth research (like ordering better laboratory tests), as well as prompting better questions to help determine a specific diagnosis.
This process, says the AMjMed article, is lost in our “electronic medical record–centered, ’4000 clicks a day’ culture.” Google search can provide a quick answer, but it “circumvents… the practice of analytical thinking” and the development of “higher-level reasoning.” This is why Verghese stresses the value of riddles in teaching and learning: “As the scientific revolution in medicine continues, and as new diseases and therapies appear,” the “canon of riddles” must grow as well.
Humility is an underappreciated skill in a time of global budgets, evidenced based approaches, and cost-containment. The bright, well-read, talented medical students who may lack humility are not uncommon.
Patient-centered care is an important aspect of the National Strategy for Quality Improvement on Health Care. As such, healthcare institutions are strongly focusing on the patient-physician relationship and the patient experience.
The editor-in-chief of Medscape, Dr. Eric Topol, visited Stanford to sit down and do an interview with our Dr. Vergese for the Medscape One-on-One online video series.
Peter Conrad, a sociologist at Brandeis University, spoke of the rise and fall of the medical authority in the doctor patient office encounter in his many scholarly articles. With the internet becoming the “elephant in the doctor’s office,” the dynamic of medical authority has certainly changed…